Eval-Driven Product Management: How to Define "Good" for AI Features
Shipping AI features without evals is how 95% of pilots fail. Here is how product managers define "good" for probabilistic features — and ship with evidence instead of hope.
Most teams ship AI features the way they ship buttons: write a spec, build it, click around once, call it done. Then it hallucinates in front of a customer. The problem isn't the model — it's that nobody defined what "good" actually means before shipping. That's the job of an eval, and writing them is fast becoming the core product-management skill of 2026.
The PRD Tells You What to Build. Evals Tell You If It Works.
For a deterministic feature, "done" is obvious: the button saves the form or it doesn't. For a probabilistic feature — a summarizer, an agent, a RAG-powered answer — "done" is a distribution. The same prompt can produce a brilliant answer on Monday and a confidently wrong one on Tuesday. A PRD that says "summarize the customer call" is meaningless without a definition of what a good summary contains, what a bad one looks like, and how often you can tolerate the bad one.
An eval is that definition made executable: a set of test cases, each with an input and a rubric for grading the output. It is the user story for a system that never behaves the same way twice.
Why This Lands on the PM, Not the ML Engineer
MIT's widely-cited 2026 finding that 95% of enterprise GenAI pilots deliver no measurable ROI is not a modeling failure — it is a product-judgment failure. An engineer can make a model score higher on a benchmark. Only the PM knows which failures actually cost you a customer. Deciding that a refund bot must never invent a policy, but may occasionally ask a clarifying question, is a product call, not an engineering one. Evals are where that judgment gets written down.
How to Write Your First Eval Set
- Collect real inputs. Pull 20–50 actual examples — support tickets, call transcripts, user queries. Synthetic cases miss the messiness that breaks models in production.
Keep reading
Is Your AI PM Tool EU AI Act Compliant? A Framework for Product Managers
Every AI tool in your stack now has to answer this question. Here is the 4-step framework we used to answer it honestly for Specky, and how to run it on your own stack in under an hour.
Customer Journey Mapping for Product Managers: Stop Guessing, Start Seeing
Most customer journey maps end up as beautiful wall art that nobody opens after the workshop. Here's how to build one that actually drives product decisions.
The PM's Weekly Review: A 30-Minute Ritual That Replaces 5 Meetings
Most PMs are drowning in sync meetings that produce no decisions. Here is the 30-minute weekly review ritual that gives you the situational awareness of five meetings in one focused session.